Coherence of comments and method implementations: a dataset and an empirical investigation

In this paper, we present the results of a manual assessment on the coherence between the comments and the implementation of 3636 methods in three open source soft- ware applications (for one of these applications, we considered two different subsequent versions) implemented in Java. The results of this assessment have been collected in a dataset we made publicly available on the Web. The creation of this dataset is based on a protocol that is detailed in this paper. We present that protocol to let researchers evaluate the goodness of our dataset and to ease its future possible extensions. Another contribution of this paper consists in preliminarily investigating on the effectiveness of adopting a Vec- tor Space Model (VSM) with the tf-idf schema to discriminate coherent and non-coherent methods. We observed that the lexical similarity alone is not sufficient for this distinc- tion, while encouraging results have been obtained by applying an Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier on the whole vector space.