IRIS

To evaluate the relation between elective cesarean section and vertical transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), we performed a meta-analysis using data on individual patients from 15 prospective cohort studies. North American and European studies of at least 100 mother-child pairs were included in the meta-analysis. Uniform definitions of modes of delivery were used. Elective cesarean sections were defined as those performed before onset of labor and rupture of membranes. Multivariate logistic-regression analysis was used to adjust for other factors known to be associated with vertical transmission. The primary analysis included data on 8533 mother-child pairs. After adjustment for receipt of antiretroviral therapy, maternal stage of disease, and infant birth weight, the likelihood of vertical transmission of HIV-1 was decreased by approximately 50 percent with elective cesarean section, as compared with other modes of delivery (adjusted odds ratio, 0.43; 95 percent confidence interval, 0.33 to 0.56). The results were similar when the study population was limited to those with rupture of membranes shortly before delivery. The likelihood of transmission was reduced by approximately 87 percent with both elective cesarean section and receipt of antiretroviral therapy during the prenatal, intrapartum, and neonatal periods, as compared with other modes of delivery and the absence of therapy (adjusted odds ratio, 0.13; 95 percent confidence interval, 0.09 to 0.19). Among mother-child pairs receiving antiretroviral therapy during the prenatal, intrapartum, and neonatal periods, rates of vertical transmission were 2.0 percent among the 196 mothers who underwent elective cesarean section and 7.3 percent among the 1255 mothers with other modes of delivery. The results of this meta-analysis suggest that elective cesarean section reduces the risk of transmission of HIV-1 from mother to child independently of the effects of treatment with zidovudine.

The mode of delivery and the risk of vertical transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1--a meta-analysis of 15 prospective cohort studies. The International Perinatal HIV Group / Andiman, W.; Boucher, M.; Burns, D.; Bryson, Y.; Farley, J.; Fowler, H.; Gabiano, C.; Galli, L.; Hutto, C.; Kind, C.; Korber, B.; Kovacs, A.; Krogstad, P.; Landesman, S.; Lapointe, N.; Lemay, M.; Lew, J.; Mandelbrot, L.; Mayaux, M. J.; Mellins, R.; Minkoff, H.; Mofenson, L.; Nielsen, K.; Newell, M. L.; Pardi, G.; Peavy, H.; Peckham, C.; Read, J.; Rother, C.; Rudin, C.; Scott, G.; Semprini, A.; Shearer, W.; Simonds, R.; Simpson, B.; Stek, A.; Tovo, P. A.; Tuomala, R.; Van Dyke, R.; Weedon, J.; de Martino, M.; Lindsay, M.; Belair, S.; Chan, L.; Harris, D.; Kalish, L.; Muenz, L.; Nugent, R.; Schluchter, M.; Durako, S.; Goodwin, S.; Mitchell, R.; Nourjah, P.; Owen, W.; Widmayer, S.; Bardeguez, A.; Hanson, C.; Wiznia, A.; Luzuriaga, K.; Viscarello, R.; Ho, D.; Koup, R.; Chen, I.; Mullins, J.; Wolinsky, S.; Walker, B.; Ammann, A.; Clapp, S.; Mcdonald, D.; Fauvel, M.; Hankins, C.; Samson, J.; Bailey, A.; Giaquinto, C.; Ruga, E.; De Rossi, A.; Truscia, D.; Grosch Worner, I.; Schafer, A.; Mok, J.; Johnstone, F.; Jiminez, J.; de Alba, C.; Garcia Rodriguez, M.; Bates, I.; de Jose, I.; Hawkins, F.; Zapico, R. M.; Asensi Botet, F.; Otero, M.; Perez Tamarit, D.; Moya, A.; Galbis, M.; Scherpbier, H.; Boer, K.; Bohlin, A.; Lindgren, S.; Ehrnst, A.; Anzen, B.; Belfrage, E.; Levy, J.; Alimenti, A.; Barlow, P.; Ferrazin, A.; De Maria, A.; Gotta, C.; Maritati, V.; Mur, A.; Rovira, M.; Paya, A.; Coll, O.; Fortuny, C.; Boguna, J.; Caro, M. C.; Canet, Y.; Pardi, G.; Ravizza, M.; Castagna, C.; Fiore, S.; Guerra, B.; Lanari, M.; Bianchi, S.; Bovicelli, L.; Prati, E.; Duse, M.; Soresina, A.; Scaravelli, G.; De Santis, M.; Muggiasca, M.; Vigano, A.; Marchisio, P.; Iasci, A.; Spinillo, A.; Bucceri, A.; Grossi, E.; Rancilio, L.; Della Torre, M.; Dallacasa, P.; Soresina, A.; Pachi, A.; Principi, N.; Muggiasca, M.; Marchisio, P.; Zara, C.; Vignali, M.; Rossi, G.; Rancilio, L.; Selvaggi, L.; Greco, P.; Vimercati, A.; Massi, G.; Innocenti, T.; Fiscella, A.; Sansone, M.; Benedetto, C.; Tibaldi, C.; Ziarati, N.; Tadrist, B.; Thevenicau, D.; Gondry, J.; Paulard, B.; Alisy, C.; Brault, D.; Tordjeman, P.; Mamou, J.; Rozan, M.; Colombani, D.; Pincemaille, O.; Salvetti, A.; Chabanier, C.; Hernandorena, X.; Leroy, J.; Schaal, J.; Balde, P.; Faucher, P.; Lachassinne, E.; Benoit, S.; Douard, D.; Hocke, C.; Barjot, P.; Brouard, J; Delattre, P; Stien, L; Audibert, F; Labrune, P; Vial, M; Mazy, F; Sitbon, D; Crenn Hebert, C; Floch Tudal, C; Akakpo, R; Daveau, C; Leblanc, A; Cesbron, P; Duval Arnould, H; Huraux Rendu, C; Lemerle, S; Touboul, C; Guerin, M; Maingueneau, C; Reynaud, I; Rousseau, T; Ercoil, V; Lanza, M; Denavit, M; Garnier, J; Lahsinat, K; Pia, R; Allouche, C; Nardou, M; Grall, F; May, A; Dallot, M; Lhuillier, P; Cecile, W; Mezin, R; Balde, P; Bech, A; Lobut, J; Algava, G; Dermesay, Ac; Busuttil, R; Jacquemot, M; Bader Meunier, B; Fridman, S; Codaccioni, X; Maxingue, F; Thomas, D; Alain, J; De Lumley, L; Tabaste, J; Salin, Pb; Seaume, H; Guichard, A; Kebaili, K; Roussouly, C; Botto, C; De Lanete, A; Wipff, P; Cravello, L; De Boisse, P; Leclaire, M; Michel, G; Crumiere, C; Lefevre, V; Le Lorier, B; Pauly, I; Robichez, B; Seguy, D; Dehlinger, M; Rideau, F; Talon, P; Benos, P; Huret, C; Nicolas, J; Heller Roussin, B; Saint Leger, S; Delaporte, M; Hubert, C; De Sarcus, B; Karoubi, P; Mechinaud, F; Bertcrottiere, D; Bongain, A; Monpoux, F; De Gennes, C; Devianne, F; Nisand, I; Rousset, M; Karoubi, P; Mouchnino, G; Muray, J; Munzer, M; Quereux, C; Brossard, V; Clavier, B; Allemon, M; Rotten, D; Stephan, J; Varlet, M; Guyot, B; Narey, P; Bardinet, F; De Caunes, F; Jeny, R; Robin, M; Bouley, Ar; Savey, L; Berrebi, A; Tricoire, J; Borderon, J; Fignon, A; Guillot, F; Maria, B; Broyard, A; Chitrit, Y; Firtion, G; Mandelbrot, L; Pillet, Ml; Parat, S; Boissinot, C; Garec, N; Levine, M; Ottenwalter, A; Schaller, F; Vilmer, B; Courpotin, C; Brunner, C; Ciraru Vigneron, N; Hatem Gantzer, G; Heller Roussin, B; Fritel, X; Wallet, A; Bouille, J; Milliez, J; Mrejen, Db; Dermer, E; Noseda, G; Bardou, D; Cressaty, J; Francoual, C; Moncomble, Cc; Cohen, H; Blanche, S; Bastion, H; Benifla, J; Benkhatar, F; Berkane, N; Herve, F; Ronzier, M; Mayaux, Mj; de Martino, M; Tovo, Pa; Galli, L; Gabiano, C; Ferraris, G; Rancillo, L; Bucceri, A; Tulisso, S; Scolfaro, C; Riva, C; Vierucci, A; de Luca, M; Farina, S; Fundaro, C; Genovese, O; Mercu, G; Forni, G; Stegagno, M; Falconieri, P; Zuccotti, G; Riva, E; Cellini, M; Baraldi, C; Consolini, R; Palla, G; Ruggeri, M; Pignata, Claudio; Guarino, Alfredo; Osimani, P; Metri, A; Antonellini, A; Benaglia, G; Romano, A; Dallacasa, P; De Mattia, D; Caselli, D; Boni, S; Dell'Erba, G; Bassanetti, F; Sticca, M; Timpano, C; Magnani, C; Salvatore, C; Gambaretto, G; Lipreri, R; Tornaghi, R; Pinzani, R; Cecchi, M; Bezzi, T; Battisti, L; Bresciani, E; Gattinara, G; Berrino, R; Pellegatta, A; Mazza, A; Baldi, F; Micheletti, E; Ruga, E; Altobelli, R; Deiana, M; Colnaghi, C; Tarallo, L; Tondo, U; Anastasio, E; Duse, M; Chiriaco, P; Contardi, I; Ruggeri, C; Ibba, P; Scott, G; Hutto, C; O'Sullivan, M; Malmsberry, A; Willoughby, A; Burns, D; Goedert, J; Landesman, S; Minkoff, H; Mendez, H; Holman, S; Rubinstein, A; Durako, S; Muenz, L; Goodwin, S; Nesheim, S; Lindsay, M; Clark, S; Lee, F; Nahmias, A; Sawyer, M; Vink, P; Farley, J; Alger, L; Abrams, E; Bamji, M; Lambert, G; Schoenbaum, E; Thea, D; Thomas, P; Weedon, J; Palumbo, P; Bardeguez, A; Denny, T; Oleske, J; Simonds, R; Orloff, S; Ethier Ives, J; Rogers, M; Schluchter, M; Kutner, M; Kaplan, S; Kattan, M; Lipshultz, S; Mellins, R; Shearer, W; Peavy, H; Sopko, G; Sloand, E; Wu, M; Kind, C; Nadal, D; Rudin, C; Siegrist, Ca; Wyler, Ca; Cheseaux, Jj; Aebi, C; Gnehm, H; Schubiger, G; Klingler, J; Hunziker, U; Kuchler, H; Gianinazzi, M; Buhlmann, U; Rudin, C; Biedermann, K; Lauper, U; Irion, O; Brunelli, A; Spoletini, G; Schreyer, A; Kind, C; Hosli, I; Saurenmann, E; Drack, G; Isenschmid, M; Poorbeik, M; Schupbach, J; Perrin, L; Erb, P; Joller, H; Bryson, Y; Dillon, M; Nielsen, R; Boyer, P; Liao, D; Keller, M; Deveikis, A; Kovacs, A; Stek, A; Chan, L; Rother, C; Khoury, M; Diaz, C; Pacheco Acosta, E; Tuomala, R; Cooper, E; Mesthene, D; Pitt, J; Higgins, A; Mendez, H; Moroso, G; Rich, K; Turpin, D; Cooper, N; Fowler, M; Nugent, R; Smeriglio, V; Mckinlay, S; Kalish, L; Ellis, S; Andiman, W; Simpson, B.. - In: THE NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE. - ISSN 0028-4793. - ELETTRONICO. - 340:(1999), pp. 977-987.

The mode of delivery and the risk of vertical transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1--a meta-analysis of 15 prospective cohort studies. The International Perinatal HIV Group.

PIGNATA, CLAUDIO;GUARINO, ALFREDO;
1999

Abstract

To evaluate the relation between elective cesarean section and vertical transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), we performed a meta-analysis using data on individual patients from 15 prospective cohort studies. North American and European studies of at least 100 mother-child pairs were included in the meta-analysis. Uniform definitions of modes of delivery were used. Elective cesarean sections were defined as those performed before onset of labor and rupture of membranes. Multivariate logistic-regression analysis was used to adjust for other factors known to be associated with vertical transmission. The primary analysis included data on 8533 mother-child pairs. After adjustment for receipt of antiretroviral therapy, maternal stage of disease, and infant birth weight, the likelihood of vertical transmission of HIV-1 was decreased by approximately 50 percent with elective cesarean section, as compared with other modes of delivery (adjusted odds ratio, 0.43; 95 percent confidence interval, 0.33 to 0.56). The results were similar when the study population was limited to those with rupture of membranes shortly before delivery. The likelihood of transmission was reduced by approximately 87 percent with both elective cesarean section and receipt of antiretroviral therapy during the prenatal, intrapartum, and neonatal periods, as compared with other modes of delivery and the absence of therapy (adjusted odds ratio, 0.13; 95 percent confidence interval, 0.09 to 0.19). Among mother-child pairs receiving antiretroviral therapy during the prenatal, intrapartum, and neonatal periods, rates of vertical transmission were 2.0 percent among the 196 mothers who underwent elective cesarean section and 7.3 percent among the 1255 mothers with other modes of delivery. The results of this meta-analysis suggest that elective cesarean section reduces the risk of transmission of HIV-1 from mother to child independently of the effects of treatment with zidovudine.
1999
The mode of delivery and the risk of vertical transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1--a meta-analysis of 15 prospective cohort studies. The International Perinatal HIV Group / Andiman, W.; Boucher, M.; Burns, D.; Bryson, Y.; Farley, J.; Fowler, H.; Gabiano, C.; Galli, L.; Hutto, C.; Kind, C.; Korber, B.; Kovacs, A.; Krogstad, P.; Landesman, S.; Lapointe, N.; Lemay, M.; Lew, J.; Mandelbrot, L.; Mayaux, M. J.; Mellins, R.; Minkoff, H.; Mofenson, L.; Nielsen, K.; Newell, M. L.; Pardi, G.; Peavy, H.; Peckham, C.; Read, J.; Rother, C.; Rudin, C.; Scott, G.; Semprini, A.; Shearer, W.; Simonds, R.; Simpson, B.; Stek, A.; Tovo, P. A.; Tuomala, R.; Van Dyke, R.; Weedon, J.; de Martino, M.; Lindsay, M.; Belair, S.; Chan, L.; Harris, D.; Kalish, L.; Muenz, L.; Nugent, R.; Schluchter, M.; Durako, S.; Goodwin, S.; Mitchell, R.; Nourjah, P.; Owen, W.; Widmayer, S.; Bardeguez, A.; Hanson, C.; Wiznia, A.; Luzuriaga, K.; Viscarello, R.; Ho, D.; Koup, R.; Chen, I.; Mullins, J.; Wolinsky, S.; Walker, B.; Ammann, A.; Clapp, S.; Mcdonald, D.; Fauvel, M.; Hankins, C.; Samson, J.; Bailey, A.; Giaquinto, C.; Ruga, E.; De Rossi, A.; Truscia, D.; Grosch Worner, I.; Schafer, A.; Mok, J.; Johnstone, F.; Jiminez, J.; de Alba, C.; Garcia Rodriguez, M.; Bates, I.; de Jose, I.; Hawkins, F.; Zapico, R. M.; Asensi Botet, F.; Otero, M.; Perez Tamarit, D.; Moya, A.; Galbis, M.; Scherpbier, H.; Boer, K.; Bohlin, A.; Lindgren, S.; Ehrnst, A.; Anzen, B.; Belfrage, E.; Levy, J.; Alimenti, A.; Barlow, P.; Ferrazin, A.; De Maria, A.; Gotta, C.; Maritati, V.; Mur, A.; Rovira, M.; Paya, A.; Coll, O.; Fortuny, C.; Boguna, J.; Caro, M. C.; Canet, Y.; Pardi, G.; Ravizza, M.; Castagna, C.; Fiore, S.; Guerra, B.; Lanari, M.; Bianchi, S.; Bovicelli, L.; Prati, E.; Duse, M.; Soresina, A.; Scaravelli, G.; De Santis, M.; Muggiasca, M.; Vigano, A.; Marchisio, P.; Iasci, A.; Spinillo, A.; Bucceri, A.; Grossi, E.; Rancilio, L.; Della Torre, M.; Dallacasa, P.; Soresina, A.; Pachi, A.; Principi, N.; Muggiasca, M.; Marchisio, P.; Zara, C.; Vignali, M.; Rossi, G.; Rancilio, L.; Selvaggi, L.; Greco, P.; Vimercati, A.; Massi, G.; Innocenti, T.; Fiscella, A.; Sansone, M.; Benedetto, C.; Tibaldi, C.; Ziarati, N.; Tadrist, B.; Thevenicau, D.; Gondry, J.; Paulard, B.; Alisy, C.; Brault, D.; Tordjeman, P.; Mamou, J.; Rozan, M.; Colombani, D.; Pincemaille, O.; Salvetti, A.; Chabanier, C.; Hernandorena, X.; Leroy, J.; Schaal, J.; Balde, P.; Faucher, P.; Lachassinne, E.; Benoit, S.; Douard, D.; Hocke, C.; Barjot, P.; Brouard, J; Delattre, P; Stien, L; Audibert, F; Labrune, P; Vial, M; Mazy, F; Sitbon, D; Crenn Hebert, C; Floch Tudal, C; Akakpo, R; Daveau, C; Leblanc, A; Cesbron, P; Duval Arnould, H; Huraux Rendu, C; Lemerle, S; Touboul, C; Guerin, M; Maingueneau, C; Reynaud, I; Rousseau, T; Ercoil, V; Lanza, M; Denavit, M; Garnier, J; Lahsinat, K; Pia, R; Allouche, C; Nardou, M; Grall, F; May, A; Dallot, M; Lhuillier, P; Cecile, W; Mezin, R; Balde, P; Bech, A; Lobut, J; Algava, G; Dermesay, Ac; Busuttil, R; Jacquemot, M; Bader Meunier, B; Fridman, S; Codaccioni, X; Maxingue, F; Thomas, D; Alain, J; De Lumley, L; Tabaste, J; Salin, Pb; Seaume, H; Guichard, A; Kebaili, K; Roussouly, C; Botto, C; De Lanete, A; Wipff, P; Cravello, L; De Boisse, P; Leclaire, M; Michel, G; Crumiere, C; Lefevre, V; Le Lorier, B; Pauly, I; Robichez, B; Seguy, D; Dehlinger, M; Rideau, F; Talon, P; Benos, P; Huret, C; Nicolas, J; Heller Roussin, B; Saint Leger, S; Delaporte, M; Hubert, C; De Sarcus, B; Karoubi, P; Mechinaud, F; Bertcrottiere, D; Bongain, A; Monpoux, F; De Gennes, C; Devianne, F; Nisand, I; Rousset, M; Karoubi, P; Mouchnino, G; Muray, J; Munzer, M; Quereux, C; Brossard, V; Clavier, B; Allemon, M; Rotten, D; Stephan, J; Varlet, M; Guyot, B; Narey, P; Bardinet, F; De Caunes, F; Jeny, R; Robin, M; Bouley, Ar; Savey, L; Berrebi, A; Tricoire, J; Borderon, J; Fignon, A; Guillot, F; Maria, B; Broyard, A; Chitrit, Y; Firtion, G; Mandelbrot, L; Pillet, Ml; Parat, S; Boissinot, C; Garec, N; Levine, M; Ottenwalter, A; Schaller, F; Vilmer, B; Courpotin, C; Brunner, C; Ciraru Vigneron, N; Hatem Gantzer, G; Heller Roussin, B; Fritel, X; Wallet, A; Bouille, J; Milliez, J; Mrejen, Db; Dermer, E; Noseda, G; Bardou, D; Cressaty, J; Francoual, C; Moncomble, Cc; Cohen, H; Blanche, S; Bastion, H; Benifla, J; Benkhatar, F; Berkane, N; Herve, F; Ronzier, M; Mayaux, Mj; de Martino, M; Tovo, Pa; Galli, L; Gabiano, C; Ferraris, G; Rancillo, L; Bucceri, A; Tulisso, S; Scolfaro, C; Riva, C; Vierucci, A; de Luca, M; Farina, S; Fundaro, C; Genovese, O; Mercu, G; Forni, G; Stegagno, M; Falconieri, P; Zuccotti, G; Riva, E; Cellini, M; Baraldi, C; Consolini, R; Palla, G; Ruggeri, M; Pignata, Claudio; Guarino, Alfredo; Osimani, P; Metri, A; Antonellini, A; Benaglia, G; Romano, A; Dallacasa, P; De Mattia, D; Caselli, D; Boni, S; Dell'Erba, G; Bassanetti, F; Sticca, M; Timpano, C; Magnani, C; Salvatore, C; Gambaretto, G; Lipreri, R; Tornaghi, R; Pinzani, R; Cecchi, M; Bezzi, T; Battisti, L; Bresciani, E; Gattinara, G; Berrino, R; Pellegatta, A; Mazza, A; Baldi, F; Micheletti, E; Ruga, E; Altobelli, R; Deiana, M; Colnaghi, C; Tarallo, L; Tondo, U; Anastasio, E; Duse, M; Chiriaco, P; Contardi, I; Ruggeri, C; Ibba, P; Scott, G; Hutto, C; O'Sullivan, M; Malmsberry, A; Willoughby, A; Burns, D; Goedert, J; Landesman, S; Minkoff, H; Mendez, H; Holman, S; Rubinstein, A; Durako, S; Muenz, L; Goodwin, S; Nesheim, S; Lindsay, M; Clark, S; Lee, F; Nahmias, A; Sawyer, M; Vink, P; Farley, J; Alger, L; Abrams, E; Bamji, M; Lambert, G; Schoenbaum, E; Thea, D; Thomas, P; Weedon, J; Palumbo, P; Bardeguez, A; Denny, T; Oleske, J; Simonds, R; Orloff, S; Ethier Ives, J; Rogers, M; Schluchter, M; Kutner, M; Kaplan, S; Kattan, M; Lipshultz, S; Mellins, R; Shearer, W; Peavy, H; Sopko, G; Sloand, E; Wu, M; Kind, C; Nadal, D; Rudin, C; Siegrist, Ca; Wyler, Ca; Cheseaux, Jj; Aebi, C; Gnehm, H; Schubiger, G; Klingler, J; Hunziker, U; Kuchler, H; Gianinazzi, M; Buhlmann, U; Rudin, C; Biedermann, K; Lauper, U; Irion, O; Brunelli, A; Spoletini, G; Schreyer, A; Kind, C; Hosli, I; Saurenmann, E; Drack, G; Isenschmid, M; Poorbeik, M; Schupbach, J; Perrin, L; Erb, P; Joller, H; Bryson, Y; Dillon, M; Nielsen, R; Boyer, P; Liao, D; Keller, M; Deveikis, A; Kovacs, A; Stek, A; Chan, L; Rother, C; Khoury, M; Diaz, C; Pacheco Acosta, E; Tuomala, R; Cooper, E; Mesthene, D; Pitt, J; Higgins, A; Mendez, H; Moroso, G; Rich, K; Turpin, D; Cooper, N; Fowler, M; Nugent, R; Smeriglio, V; Mckinlay, S; Kalish, L; Ellis, S; Andiman, W; Simpson, B.. - In: THE NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE. - ISSN 0028-4793. - ELETTRONICO. - 340:(1999), pp. 977-987.
1.1 Articolo in rivista
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
PignataC.NEJM1999.pdf

non disponibili

Tipologia: Documento in Post-print
Licenza: Accesso privato/ristretto
Dimensione 205.29 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
  Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
205.29 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11588/374788
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 81
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact