Since the end of the twentieth century, much of the world has experienced a significant increase in incarceration rates. Following the 2008 economic recession, however, the phenomenon of mass incarceration has slowed or stagnated in many Western countries for a variety of reasons. In South America, by contrast, incarceration rates have continued to rise despite the emergence of progressive political regimes in several countries. This study hypothesises that, due to their more recent processes of democratization, South American countries represent cases of post-dictatorial penal systems. As a result, their political institutions may have been more vulnerable to forms of penal populism originating both from above and from below. To test this hypothesis, the study examines the relationship between levels of interpersonal and institutional trust and levels of penal repression through a longitudinal comparison (2000-2024) involving the principal South American countries and a selection of European countries. The results show that levels of interpersonal and institutional distrust remain high across many of the countries analysed and that, in several cases, they correlate with increasing incarceration rates. Although these correlations are heterogeneous and do not allow for the establishment of direct causal relationships, they suggest that distrust constitutes a relevant dimension for understanding the region’s punitive dynamics. In this sense, the persistence of low levels of trust can be interpreted as one of the defining features of post-dictatorial penal systems in South America, alongside other factors related to processes of democratisation, state-building, and the political economy of punishment.

Penalidad Postdictatorial: entre Confianza Institucional y Niveles De Represión; La Excepción Sudamericana / Procaccini, A.. - In: SOCIOLOGIA ON LINE. - ISSN 1647-3337. - unico:1(2026), pp. 1-30. [10.30553/sociologiaonline.2026.41.5]

Penalidad Postdictatorial: entre Confianza Institucional y Niveles De Represión; La Excepción Sudamericana

Andrea Procaccini
2026

Abstract

Since the end of the twentieth century, much of the world has experienced a significant increase in incarceration rates. Following the 2008 economic recession, however, the phenomenon of mass incarceration has slowed or stagnated in many Western countries for a variety of reasons. In South America, by contrast, incarceration rates have continued to rise despite the emergence of progressive political regimes in several countries. This study hypothesises that, due to their more recent processes of democratization, South American countries represent cases of post-dictatorial penal systems. As a result, their political institutions may have been more vulnerable to forms of penal populism originating both from above and from below. To test this hypothesis, the study examines the relationship between levels of interpersonal and institutional trust and levels of penal repression through a longitudinal comparison (2000-2024) involving the principal South American countries and a selection of European countries. The results show that levels of interpersonal and institutional distrust remain high across many of the countries analysed and that, in several cases, they correlate with increasing incarceration rates. Although these correlations are heterogeneous and do not allow for the establishment of direct causal relationships, they suggest that distrust constitutes a relevant dimension for understanding the region’s punitive dynamics. In this sense, the persistence of low levels of trust can be interpreted as one of the defining features of post-dictatorial penal systems in South America, alongside other factors related to processes of democratisation, state-building, and the political economy of punishment.
2026
Penalidad Postdictatorial: entre Confianza Institucional y Niveles De Represión; La Excepción Sudamericana / Procaccini, A.. - In: SOCIOLOGIA ON LINE. - ISSN 1647-3337. - unico:1(2026), pp. 1-30. [10.30553/sociologiaonline.2026.41.5]
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
n41a05 (1).pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Versione Editoriale (PDF)
Licenza: Dominio pubblico
Dimensione 307.79 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
307.79 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11588/1067115
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact